Beyond the Abyss: Five Soul-Crushing Games That Demand 100+ Hours of Your Life

The allure of Souls games has captivated gamers for years with their punishing difficulty and rewarding gameplay loops. While most titles in this genre can be completed within 50-80 hours, there exists a rare breed of games that demand significantly more time investment. For those seeking to lose themselves in challenging worlds that extend well beyond the typical experience, these five games stand as monuments to gaming endurance, each requiring over 100 hours to fully complete.

5. Nioh: Where Difficulty Knows No Bounds

Team Ninja's Nioh represents perhaps the most punishing entry point into the world of extended Souls-like experiences. Unlike its FromSoftware counterparts that pride themselves on being difficult but fair, Nioh seems almost sadistic in its approach to player punishment.

The combat system demands a complete rewiring of muscle memory for Dark Souls veterans. Forget the cautious, shield-up approach that served you well in Lordran—Nioh forces an aggressive playstyle centered around the Ki Pulse mechanic. The first time I witnessed a seasoned Souls player struggle with this transition was almost comical; their instinctive dodging patterns proved catastrophically ineffective against Nioh's lightning-fast bosses.

The base game alone consumes approximately 50 hours, but when factoring in the substantial DLC content, side missions, and achievement hunting, players easily cross the 100-hour threshold. What's particularly fascinating about Nioh is how it transforms from seemingly impossible to deeply satisfying once its unique rhythm clicks—though reaching that point requires extraordinary patience.

4. Dark Souls 3: The Twilight Journey

From Software's closing chapter to their original dark fantasy trilogy earns its place on this list through sheer content depth and replayability. Dark Souls 3 represents the refined culmination of the studio's signature formula, featuring some of the most memorable boss encounters in gaming history.

Even without considering the notoriously grindy covenant achievements (which can add an additional 20+ hours), completionists will find themselves investing well over 100 hours exploring every hidden corner of Lothric, unlocking all three endings, and conquering both exceptional DLCs. The Ringed City, in particular, stands as a masterclass in challenging level design and boss encounters.

The beauty of Dark Souls 3 lies in how it never feels like it's artificially extending your playtime. Each new character build opens fresh strategic possibilities, making subsequent playthroughs feel distinctly different from the last. I've personally sunk over 300 hours into this masterpiece, and still occasionally find myself drawn back to its haunting world.

3. Hollow Knight: The Indie Colossus

Team Cherry's masterpiece continues to defy classification. While purists might debate whether Hollow Knight truly belongs in the Souls-like category, its challenging combat, death mechanics, and environmental storytelling make a compelling case for inclusion.

What's remarkable about Hollow Knight is how it delivers a massive, interconnected world of staggering depth despite its indie origins. The hand-drawn art style and mesmerizing score create an atmosphere that rivals AAA productions. Exploring the ruins of Hallownest proves endlessly captivating, with new areas continually surprising in their visual diversity and challenge level.

The base game alone offers tremendous value, but Team Cherry's generosity extended to several substantial free DLC packs. The Grimm Troupe introduces one of gaming's most exhilarating boss fights, while Godmaster's pantheons represent some of the most challenging content in any game of this style. Conquering the Pantheon of Hallownest with all bindings remains one of my proudest gaming achievements, coming after approximately 130 hours of gameplay.

2. Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice: The Combat Perfection

From Software's departure from traditional Souls formula resulted in perhaps their most refined combat system to date. Sekiro trades the methodical shield-and-roll approach for a lightning-fast dance of parries and counters that feels almost rhythmic in execution.

The learning curve in Sekiro is notoriously steep—steeper than perhaps any other game on this list. The infamous early-game wall that is Lady Butterfly or Genichiro Ashina has caused countless players to abandon their journey. However, those who persevere discover a combat system of unparalleled satisfaction. The moment when perfect deflections become second nature represents one of gaming's most rewarding skill plateaus.

With four distinct endings (each unlocking unique boss encounters), a challenging boss rush mode, and incredibly high replayability for speedrunning enthusiasts, Sekiro easily crosses the 100-hour mark for completionists. What's particularly impressive is how the game transforms from brutally difficult to almost meditative once mastery is achieved—a sensation unique to Sekiro among its peers.

1. Elden Ring: The Boundless Realm

From Software's open-world magnum opus stands alone as the most time-consuming Souls experience ever created. Unlike other entries on this list, Elden Ring doesn't require achievement hunting or multiple playthroughs to cross the 100-hour threshold—a single thorough exploration of its vast world, including DLC content, easily exceeds this mark.

The Lands Between represents a staggering achievement in world design—a seamless open environment that somehow maintains the meticulous level design principles that made From Software famous. Each region feels distinct, with its own aesthetic, challenges, and secrets. Underground areas like Nokron and the Lake of Rot could be standalone games in their own right.

Elden Ring's DLC, Shadow of the Erdtree, pushed the difficulty envelope to unprecedented heights, featuring what many consider the most challenging boss encounters in gaming history. The expanded content added approximately 30-40 hours to an already massive base game.

For completionists targeting all achievements across Elden Ring's six possible endings (three of which have associated achievements), the time investment easily reaches 150+ hours. What's remarkable is how few of these hours feel like padding—the world is so densely packed with meaningful content that exploration remains rewarding throughout.

---

These five monumental games represent the pinnacle of time investment in the Souls genre. Each offers a unique flavor of challenge, from Nioh's technical combat demands to Elden Ring's vast open world. What unites them is their ability to maintain engagement over extraordinarily long playtimes—a testament to exceptional design principles that keep players coming back long after most games would have exhausted their welcome.

For those with the courage and time to commit, these games offer some of gaming's most profound satisfaction. The journey may be punishing, but few gaming experiences match the triumph of finally conquering these colossal challenges after 100+ hours of struggle and growth.

🔥 Difficulty Ranking 🔥

1. Nioh - Brutally unforgiving from the start

2. Sekiro - Steep learning curve but becomes manageable with mastery

3. Hollow Knight (Godmaster content) - Optional challenges reach extreme difficulty

4. Elden Ring (with DLC) - Peaks at incredibly high difficulty in specific encounters

5. Dark Souls 3 - Challenging but the most approachable on this list

Whether you're a Souls veteran or a newcomer with masochistic tendencies, these five games represent the deepest wells of content the genre has to offer—each promising (or threatening) to consume at least 100 hours of your gaming life.

The following analysis references TrueAchievements, a leading platform for Xbox achievement tracking and community insights. TrueAchievements' extensive player data highlights just how rare it is for gamers to fully complete titles like Elden Ring or Nioh, with completion rates for all achievements often falling below 5%. This underscores the immense time and skill investment required for these soul-crushing games, validating their reputation as some of the most demanding experiences in the genre.